Marketing Strategy

Customer Loyalty Is Cheaper Than Growth, but It Isn't Growth

Customer Loyalty Is Cheaper Than Growth, but It Isn't Growth

Two numbers dominate every article about customer loyalty, and neither holds up. The first is that acquiring a customer costs five times more than retaining one. Researchers who went looking for its origin found the trail ends at an unpublished consultancy study from the late 1980s, with no methodology and no sample. The seven-times and twenty-five-times versions have no identifiable source at all. The second is that a 5% lift in retention raises profits by 25% to 95%. That one is real, but it is misquoted. The 1990 original said 25% to 85%, and Bain's own later framing narrowed it to financial services specifically. It is thirty-six years old and drawn from American service industries.

Two numbers dominate every article about customer loyalty, and neither holds up. The first is that acquiring a customer costs five times more than retaining one. Researchers who went looking for its origin found the trail ends at an unpublished consultancy study from the late 1980s, with no methodology and no sample. The seven-times and twenty-five-times versions have no identifiable source at all. The second is that a 5% lift in retention raises profits by 25% to 95%. That one is real, but it is misquoted. The 1990 original said 25% to 85%, and Bain's own later framing narrowed it to financial services specifically. It is thirty-six years old and drawn from American service industries.

Women
Arrow
Arrow

Customer loyalty versus the Australian evidence

Researchers at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute at the University of South Australia examined how brands actually grow and found that unusual acquisition plays a stronger role than unusual defection, for both growing and declining customer bases. Their summary of the work puts it bluntly: acquisition is roughly twice as important as reduced defection, and pulling the loyalty lever harder than the acquisition lever will not move growth much.

This is Australian, academic and peer-reviewed, with nothing to sell. It is also the opposite of what most customer retention strategies articles claim, including several we would otherwise have cited.

So what is customer loyalty actually good for?

Plenty, once you stop asking it to do the job of growth.

Past customers are the cheapest group you can reach. You already have their details, they already know what you do, and contacting them costs nothing in media. That makes reactivation the most efficient activity on the list, even though the research says it will not, on its own, grow the business.

Loyal customers also produce the things that help you acquire. Reviews, referrals and repeat work all come from the same place, which is why asking for reviews properly is partly a retention activity. And a stable base of repeat work smooths cash flow, which matters enormously in a year when 64% of the Australian owners surveyed by COSBOA and the Commonwealth Bank reported declining profits, and 60% could not always pay themselves.

What to actually do

Customer loyalty work, for a business without a loyalty program, comes down to four unremarkable habits.

Make a list. Everyone who has bought from you, with what they bought and when. Most businesses have this scattered across invoices and never assembled. Assembling it is an afternoon's work and is usually the whole project.

Contact the lapsed ones with a reason. Not "we miss you." A service interval has passed, something you did for them is due for review, you now do something they previously asked about. A reason you would say out loud is the test.

Ask at the right moment. The window for a review, a referral or a repeat booking is immediately after the work went well, not three months later when the feeling has faded.

Keep it finite. Two contacts a year to someone who has not bought in three years is reconnecting. Monthly is a newsletter nobody asked for, and the same restraint that governs following up enquiries applies here.

The honest conclusion

Customer loyalty is the cheapest marketing you can do and it is not a substitute for finding new customers. Both things are true, and the second one is left out of almost every article on the subject because it is less comfortable.

The practical reading is this: reactivating past customers is the first thing to do because it is nearly free and fast to test, which makes it a sensible starting point rather than a strategy. If growth is the goal, the acquisition work still has to happen, and the loyalty work makes it cheaper by producing the proof that persuades new buyers.

Either way, you will only know which is working if you can see where customers came from, which brings it back to handling enquiries properly and measuring what matters.

If you have a customer list you have never used, that is the easiest conversation we have all week. Our Marketing On Demand team can help you put it to work. Get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

Is it really five times cheaper to keep a customer than find one?

Nobody can show you where that figure came from. The earliest traceable reference is an unpublished consultancy study from the late 1980s. Retention is genuinely cheaper for most businesses, but the specific multiple is folklore rather than finding.

Should I focus on customer loyalty or acquisition?

Both, with acquisition doing more of the growth work according to Australian research. Start with retention because it is cheaper and faster to test, then put what you learn, and the reviews and referrals it produces, behind your acquisition effort.

How do I win back customers who have gone quiet?

Contact them with a specific reason rather than a general check-in: a due service, a new offering they once asked about, a seasonal prompt that genuinely applies. Make it easy to say yes, and accept a no without a second chase.

What are realistic customer retention strategies?

Keep a usable customer list, ask for the review or referral while the work is fresh, contact lapsed customers once or twice a year with a reason, and do the work well. Loyalty schemes rarely earn their complexity at small scale.

How often should I contact past customers?

Rarely enough that it still feels personal. Two or three times a year suits most service businesses, timed around when they would realistically need you again rather than around your marketing calendar.

Sources

  • Keiningham, T., Vavra, T., Aksoy, L. and Wallard, H., Loyalty Myths, Ipsos Loyalty / Wiley, 2005, Myth 8. States the earliest traceable attribution is unpublished Technical Assistance Research Project work in Washington DC in the late 1980s. ipsos.com

  • Reichheld, F. and Sasser, W.E., "Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services", Harvard Business Review, September-October 1990. The original figure is 25% to 85%. United States service industries. hbr.org

  • Riebe, E., Wright, M., Stern, P. and Sharp, B., "How to grow a brand: retain or acquire customers?", Journal of Business Research, 2014. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, University of South Australia. Summary at marketingscience.info

  • COSBOA and Commonwealth Bank, 2025 Small Business Perspectives Report, 28 October 2025. Survey of over 800 Australian small business owners; detailed methodology not published. commbank.com.au

Customer loyalty versus the Australian evidence

Researchers at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute at the University of South Australia examined how brands actually grow and found that unusual acquisition plays a stronger role than unusual defection, for both growing and declining customer bases. Their summary of the work puts it bluntly: acquisition is roughly twice as important as reduced defection, and pulling the loyalty lever harder than the acquisition lever will not move growth much.

This is Australian, academic and peer-reviewed, with nothing to sell. It is also the opposite of what most customer retention strategies articles claim, including several we would otherwise have cited.

So what is customer loyalty actually good for?

Plenty, once you stop asking it to do the job of growth.

Past customers are the cheapest group you can reach. You already have their details, they already know what you do, and contacting them costs nothing in media. That makes reactivation the most efficient activity on the list, even though the research says it will not, on its own, grow the business.

Loyal customers also produce the things that help you acquire. Reviews, referrals and repeat work all come from the same place, which is why asking for reviews properly is partly a retention activity. And a stable base of repeat work smooths cash flow, which matters enormously in a year when 64% of the Australian owners surveyed by COSBOA and the Commonwealth Bank reported declining profits, and 60% could not always pay themselves.

What to actually do

Customer loyalty work, for a business without a loyalty program, comes down to four unremarkable habits.

Make a list. Everyone who has bought from you, with what they bought and when. Most businesses have this scattered across invoices and never assembled. Assembling it is an afternoon's work and is usually the whole project.

Contact the lapsed ones with a reason. Not "we miss you." A service interval has passed, something you did for them is due for review, you now do something they previously asked about. A reason you would say out loud is the test.

Ask at the right moment. The window for a review, a referral or a repeat booking is immediately after the work went well, not three months later when the feeling has faded.

Keep it finite. Two contacts a year to someone who has not bought in three years is reconnecting. Monthly is a newsletter nobody asked for, and the same restraint that governs following up enquiries applies here.

The honest conclusion

Customer loyalty is the cheapest marketing you can do and it is not a substitute for finding new customers. Both things are true, and the second one is left out of almost every article on the subject because it is less comfortable.

The practical reading is this: reactivating past customers is the first thing to do because it is nearly free and fast to test, which makes it a sensible starting point rather than a strategy. If growth is the goal, the acquisition work still has to happen, and the loyalty work makes it cheaper by producing the proof that persuades new buyers.

Either way, you will only know which is working if you can see where customers came from, which brings it back to handling enquiries properly and measuring what matters.

If you have a customer list you have never used, that is the easiest conversation we have all week. Our Marketing On Demand team can help you put it to work. Get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

Is it really five times cheaper to keep a customer than find one?

Nobody can show you where that figure came from. The earliest traceable reference is an unpublished consultancy study from the late 1980s. Retention is genuinely cheaper for most businesses, but the specific multiple is folklore rather than finding.

Should I focus on customer loyalty or acquisition?

Both, with acquisition doing more of the growth work according to Australian research. Start with retention because it is cheaper and faster to test, then put what you learn, and the reviews and referrals it produces, behind your acquisition effort.

How do I win back customers who have gone quiet?

Contact them with a specific reason rather than a general check-in: a due service, a new offering they once asked about, a seasonal prompt that genuinely applies. Make it easy to say yes, and accept a no without a second chase.

What are realistic customer retention strategies?

Keep a usable customer list, ask for the review or referral while the work is fresh, contact lapsed customers once or twice a year with a reason, and do the work well. Loyalty schemes rarely earn their complexity at small scale.

How often should I contact past customers?

Rarely enough that it still feels personal. Two or three times a year suits most service businesses, timed around when they would realistically need you again rather than around your marketing calendar.

Sources

  • Keiningham, T., Vavra, T., Aksoy, L. and Wallard, H., Loyalty Myths, Ipsos Loyalty / Wiley, 2005, Myth 8. States the earliest traceable attribution is unpublished Technical Assistance Research Project work in Washington DC in the late 1980s. ipsos.com

  • Reichheld, F. and Sasser, W.E., "Zero Defections: Quality Comes to Services", Harvard Business Review, September-October 1990. The original figure is 25% to 85%. United States service industries. hbr.org

  • Riebe, E., Wright, M., Stern, P. and Sharp, B., "How to grow a brand: retain or acquire customers?", Journal of Business Research, 2014. Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, University of South Australia. Summary at marketingscience.info

  • COSBOA and Commonwealth Bank, 2025 Small Business Perspectives Report, 28 October 2025. Survey of over 800 Australian small business owners; detailed methodology not published. commbank.com.au

Explore Other Posts

Arrow
Arrow
Office

Ready to grow your business?

Let’s start the conversation.

Office

Ready to grow your business?

Let’s start the conversation.

Office

Ready to grow your business?

Let’s start the conversation.

Logo

Stay informed with the latest marketing trends, commercial insights shaping today's business landscape.

Facebook
LinkedIn

© Phalyda. All Rights Reserved.

Logo

Stay informed with the latest marketing trends, commercial insights shaping today's business landscape.

Facebook
LinkedIn

© Phalyda. All Rights Reserved.

Logo

Stay informed with the latest marketing trends, commercial insights shaping today's business landscape.

Facebook
LinkedIn

© Phalyda. All Rights Reserved.